Are you a new parent looking for the best pacifier for your breastfed baby?

We know how hard it can be to find the right product that will work with your needs and make sure your little one is comfortable. That's why we've put together this article full of tips and tricks to help you find the perfect pacifier!

You'll learn all about what makes a great pacifier, which ones are designed specifically for breastfed babies, and even some fun facts about why they're so important. Plus, we have some recommendations on our favorite products so you don't have to waste time searching through endless options.

Read on now to discover everything you need to know about finding the best pacifiers for breastfed babies!

Quick Top 5! #1 Tommee Tippee, #2 MAM, #3 Nanobebe, #4 Ninni Co, #5 Itzy Ritzy - Read on to hear why we love these!

How Mothers Best Buys Chooses The Best

As a busy mom, you don't have the time to scroll through online reviews or shop around for the best pacifier for your breastfed baby.

You want to make sure that you're getting the best product without wasting your precious time and money on something that won't work. With so many different products out there, it can be overwhelming trying to figure out which one is right for you and your little one.

Mothers Best Buys has done all of the hard work for you! Our expert reviewers have spent countless hours researching different pacifiers so that we can provide you with an article full of our top picks - saving you both time and money in finding what's best for your baby.

Babies love pacifiers 

What's the deal with pacifiers?

Breastfeeding can be a wonderful bonding experience between a mother and her baby, but it can also come with its own set of challenges. One of those challenges is finding the right pacifier for your breastfed baby.

While there are some pacifiers on the market designed specifically for breastfed babies, you don't necessarily need to shell out extra cash to find a pacifier that works. The key is to look for a pacifier with a nipple that closely mimics the shape and feel of a breast.

Some parents have found success with pacifiers that have a rounded or flattened nipple rather than a traditional, elongated one. Ultimately, the right pacifier for your breastfed baby will depend on their individual preferences.

Can you get pacifiers that mimic the breast?

Yes, there are pacifiers that are designed to resemble a breast. These types of pacifiers typically have a curved or bell-shaped teat, similar to the shape of the mother’s nipple during breastfeeding.

They can also feature an elongated teat with a wider base and bulbous tip for a more realistic feel. Not only does this help infants to latch on easier but they generally find it comforting as well.

These kinds of pacifiers usually feature either an orthodontic or symmetrical design, which allows them to fit into the baby's mouth without putting too much pressure on their delicate gums and teeth.

This is beneficial in preventing problems such as misalignment of their jaw, teeth and palate caused by prolonged use of other standard shaped pacifier designs.

Additionally, these types of pacifiers may also come with ventilation holes that allow air through for greater comfort when sucking - which helps reduce any discomfort from saliva build-up around the baby’s mouth area.  All these features make them ideal for both newborns and older babies who may still require soothers at night time in order to settle themselves down and sleep more peacefully throughout the night.

Tommy Tippee Breast-like Pacifier

Best skin-like feel

Check Price On Amazon

Why Parents Love This!

The Tommy Tippee breast-like pacifier is designed to provide a natural, breast-like feel for your baby. With its symmetrical design and gentle curve shape, it helps keep the pacifier away from your baby’s face while also increasing ventilation and avoiding skin irritation.

The best part? It has no silicone taste so you don't have to worry about strange flavors! This stylish pacifier will make sure that your little one stays content throughout their day.

With Tommy Tippee's Breast-like Pacifier, you can rest assured that your baby is getting the comfort and security they need.

Good To Know

Tommee Tippee's Breast-like Pacifier is the perfect choice for parents looking to provide comfort and security for their little ones. Offering two sizes, 0-6 months and 6-18 months, this pacifier provides a natural fit that closely mimics mom’s breast to help reduce colic and discomfort in babies.

It also features an easy cleaning design with no small parts or crevices where dirt can get trapped, making it easier than ever to ensure optimal hygiene.

Plus, it is made from BPA free materials so you can rest assured your baby is safe while they enjoy their soothing time. The Tommee Tippee Breast-like Pacifier comes in packs of 2 or 4 and offers various colors so you can find the perfect fit for your little one!


✔️ Skin-like feel

✔️ BPA Free

✔️Easy to clean

✔️No silicone taste

MAM Original New Born Pacifier

Self sterilizing case

Check Price On Amazon

Why Parents Love This!

The MAM Newborn Pacifier is designed to help your little one stay comfortable and happy. Its silky SkinSoft material mimics the shape of a breast for a familiar sucking experience, while its curved shield prevents moisture buildup and skin irritation.

Moreover, it comes with an innovative self-sterilizing case that can be easily cleaned in just water and microwaved or used as handy storage container.

With this pacifier from MAM, you can keep your baby safe, comforted, and healthy!  Thanks to its modern design, you can be sure your baby will love the feel and comfort of the MAM pacifier. So give your little one the best start possible and choose our pacifier today!

Good To Know

The new born pacifier is designed with your baby's comfort in mind. It's extra tiny for 0-2 months, and comes in a set of two so that you always have one ready to go if the other gets lost.

The pacifier also comes in six different colors, allowing you to choose the perfect shade for your little one.

It is made from BPS and BPA free materials which are durable yet flexible enough to be comfortable for even the youngest babies. Plus, it features an ergonomic design that will help keep your baby’s mouth aligned properly while they are sucking on it.


✔️ Soft skin like material

✔️ BPS / BPA Free

✔️ Flexible and durable

✔️ Sanitizing container

Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers

One piece silicone design

Check Price On Amazon

Why Parents Love This

The Nanobebe pacifier is an award-winning pacifier designed to help keep your baby safe and comfortable. Its made of one piece so to reduce choking hazard.

The ergonomic shape curves around your baby's face for added comfort, while the unique one-piece silicone design adheres to the American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines for safe pacifiers. It features ultra-soft silicone that mimics mom's skin, which helps eliminate nipple confusion and soothes breastfeeding babies.

And with built-in open side vents providing additional air flow, you can feel confident knowing that your little one is getting all the air they need while using this product. Easy to clean too – just throw it in the sterilizer! With Nanobebe, you're giving your child a quality product without having to compromise on safety or convenience.

Good To Know

This baby pacifier is the perfect choice for parents looking for a flexible, safe and comfortable pacifier. It comes come in sets of two or four, making them ideal for multiples. The colors available are pink, grey, teal and white to match any nursery decor.

They are also available in sizes 0-3 months, 3-6 months and 4-36 months so as your baby grows you can be sure their pacifier will always fit comfortably.

All their products are BPA free and have been designed with safety top of mind - giving parents peace of mind that they've made the right choice.


✔️ One piece silicone style

✔️ BPA Free

✔️ Skin like silicone

✔️ Ventilation

Ninni Co Breastfeeding Promoting Pacifier

Closely resembles the areola 

Check Price On Amazon

Why Parents Love This!

Ninni Co's Breastfeeding Promoting Pacifier is the perfect choice for new parents looking to maintain their baby's natural feeding pattern. Its skin-like texture provides a comfortable and calming experience that closely mimics an areola and nipple—helping your little one transition from breastfeeding with ease.

These orthodontic pacifiers are made of 100% medical grade silicone, BPA free, Phthalate Free, PVC free and proudly made in USA.

It has been endorsed by over 100 professionals including doctors, dentists and therapists as being the best option for breastfed babies. With its high quality design, it supports healthy orofacial development while still soothing your infant just like nursing!

Good To Know

This pack of two pacifiers from [Brand Name] is designed to help soothe babies and provide comfort. The natural skin tones help with a breast fed baby, making it easy for them to feel at ease.

It also provides parents with convenience as it can be safely placed in a dishwasher for easy cleaning. Additionally, its lightweight design ensures that there is minimal pressure on the baby’s mouth while they are using it.


✔️ Mimics areola nd nipple

✔️ BPA Free

✔️ Dishwasher safe

✔️ Made in USA

Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother

Best collapsible handle

Check Price On Amazon

Why Parents Love This!

The Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother is an innovative and user-friendly solution to meeting your baby's needs. This 100% food grade silicone product features two vent holes for breathability as well as a single part design and collapsible handle for added safety.

Its nipple shape is soft and durable, making it perfect for newborns or breastfed babies. You can rest assured that this product meets the highest ASTM safety standards so you can feel confident in offering your little one a safe and comfortable way to enjoy their bottle time.

Good To Know

The perfect pacifier for your little one is now available in a pack of two! Their range of pacifiers are made with BPA free and latex free silicone, ensuring that they are safe as well as comfortable for your baby.

With an array of different colors to choose from, you can make sure that the pacifier matches your style and aesthetic.


✔️ BPA Free

✔️ Collapsible handle

✔️ One piece design

✔️ Varius colors

10 tips about pacifiers for breastfed babies

  1. Wait until breastfeeding is well-established before introducing a pacifier, usually at least 3-4 weeks.
  2. Choose a pacifier with a nipple shape similar to the breast to avoid nipple confusion.
  3. Limit pacifier use to sleep times or during fussy periods, rather than using it as a constant soother.
  4. Check that the pacifier is clean and in good condition before giving it to your baby.
  5. Avoid dipping the pacifier in any sweet substances as this can lead to tooth decay.
  6. Don't force the pacifier on your baby if they aren't interested.
  7. Be aware that overuse of a pacifier can interfere with breastfeeding and reduce milk supply.
  8. Try different pacifier brands and types to find the one that works best for your baby.
  9. Consider replacing the pacifier regularly, as they can become worn and eventually break down.
  10. Remember that pacifiers are a personal choice and not all babies will take one. It's important to listen to your baby's cues and respond to their needs accordingly.

For more advice on anything breastfeeding related, check out our selection of the top rated breastfeeding books.

So Final Thoughts On The Best Pacifiers For Breastfed babies

When it comes to finding the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, you can’t go wrong with any of these top-rated products. Each one is designed with your baby's safety and comfort in mind, so you know they are getting quality care when using them.

Plus, their unique designs make them a great choice for both mom and baby! Whether you're looking for a traditional shield-shaped design or something more modern like an orthodontic shape that mimics breastfeeding, there's sure to be an option here that works perfectly for your little one.

With all these options available at such reasonable prices, now is definitely the time to start shopping around and find the perfect pacifier for your little bundle of joy so your breast can get some rest. And to make those night feeds easier, a sleep nursing bra would help wonders!

Are you one of those lucky moms who makes enough milk that you can go ahead and store some for future use? If so please check out these amazing articles where we have found the ultimate breastmilk bags and bottles that you can use to pump, feed and store your milk.

And if you're a mom who expresses, we've the best pumps for working moms, and the top rated Medela machines for you.

Finally, help get back to your stylish self with one of these functional and fashionable nursing tops. Breastfeeding doesn't have to be all about ill-fitting clothes.

Best Pacifier For A Breastfed Baby FAQs

Shopping for baby items can be overwhelming, especially when it comes to pacifiers. With so many styles and brands available, how do you know which one is best?

You want the best for your little one and don't want to make a mistake with something as important as their pacifier. Not only that, but you're also worried about spending money on something that won't work or isn't safe.

Don’t worry! We have all the answers to help you find the perfect pacifier for your breastfed baby. Our FAQs provide clear and concise information so that you can purchase with complete confidence knowing that you are getting exactly what's right for your little one!

Is it okay to introduce a pacifier to my baby?

Yes, it is completely safe and beneficial to introduce your baby to a pacifier. Studies show that using one can do wonders in terms of helping with comfort and self-soothing, all while reducing the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS).

How should I clean a pacifier?

To keep your baby safe and free from bacteria, you should wash their pacifiers daily with hot water and soap or run them through the dishwasher if possible. You can also throw them in the sterilizer if you have one.Make sure that they are completely dry before giving them back to your little one.

Does using a pacifier reduce breastfeeding time?

Not necessarily! The use of a pacifier does not mean that you have failed at achieving successful breastfeeding sessions—it just means that you turned to another reliable source for calming down your child in moments where verbal comforting doesn’t work any longer.

Should I stop using the “binky” when my child turns one year old?

Some experts recommend ceasing usage of the binky past age three months due its effects on proper teeth development and speech. However, many parents choose to keep it around until they’re little one turns one year old or longer if needed. You can begin introducing the idea of weaning off slowly so that your baby has time to adjust and not feel overwhelmed by the sudden disappearance of their favorite source of comfort.

When should I start using a pacifier with my newborn baby?

You can introduce your baby to the binky from birth if needed, but it’s best to wait until they are at least three weeks old. This timing is perfect since by this point most infants have already established their breastfeeding routine and won’t be confused by the presence of a new object. Some breastfed babies refuse the pacifier, it all depends on preference.

Is there anything I should avoid when using a pacifier?

Yes! Make sure that you don’t cover your baby’s face (especially baby's nose) or ears with the binky, as this can increase the risk of suffocation. Also, try to avoid using flavored pacifiers and make sure that the size is appropriate for your child’s age. Lastly, discard any pacifier that looks worn out in order to ensure your little one’s safety.

Our website is a part of the Amazon affiliate program. This means that if we provide a link to an Amazon product, it is likely an affiliate product, and we may receive a commission from your purchase. This helps us cover our expenses for research and writing and keeps us doing what we love, helping you!